Court Finds San Francisco Custodians Illegally Fired for Picketing

May 3, 2021

Last week the Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals overturned the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) ruling on a labor dispute from 2014. The court ruled that custodians in San Francisco were illegally fired by their employer in 2014 for picketing an office building, MSN reports.

In the fall of 2014, custodial employees from Preferred Building Services sought help from Service Employees International Union (SEIU) Local 87 in addressing their concerns about low wages, poor working conditions, and alleged sexual harassment from their manager—Rafael Ortiz, owner of Ortiz Janitorial Services.

The SEIU Local 87 president suggested the custodians picket outside of their employer’s building, so the workers did so on October 29, 2014 and November 19, 2014. In response, Ortiz fired four of the picketers. The custodians’ employer, Preferred Building Services, terminated its contracts with Ortiz Janitorial Services and with the building’s management company, Harvest Properties, 30 days later, and many of the remaining custodians were laid off.

SEIU Local 87 filed a charge with the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) alleging that Preferred and Ortiz engaged in unfair labor practices and fired the custodian employees for picketing and union activity. NLRB sided with the employer and ordered the complaint dismissed in its entirety. The union filed petition for review at the Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.

The court ruled 3-0 that the employees were fired illegally, siding with the union. The court panel said that the picketers acted legally and were entitled to seek support from building tenants.


Latest Articles

Examining the Options in Customized Facility Software
November 18, 2026 Connor O’Brien

Examining the Options in Customized Facility Software

November 16, 2026 Ilan Rubinsztein

Plan for Storms on Sunny Days

November 11, 2026 Jeff Cross

A Building Full of Carpet Isn’t Always a Building Full of Profit

Sponsored Articles

Every Breath Counts
November 6, 2026

Every Breath Counts

October 26, 2026

Better Wiping Products Start with Sellars

October 23, 2026

What Is Cleaning Really Costing You?

Recent News

Kathleen Misovic and Elizabeth Christenson at ISSA Show North America 2026

Inside the 2026 BSC Landscape: Labor, Tech & the Race to Stand Out

ISSA Show Celebrates Innovation Program Award Winners

From Vision to Action: ISSA Celebrates Progress and People